after recent development i’ve come to the conclusion that i’m vibing a lot with short story collection books… am looking for good recommendations u_u i guess genre is kind of open though:)
actually im curious to hear why you enjoyed her body and other parties because i found it so underwhelming? i read it last month and the first story was really good but none of the others really lived it up to it. but thats just my opinion of course!!!
ambiguity machines sounds awesome!! and i'll look into the others as well i really appreciate your comment
Ah, that's taste for you! The first story was my favorite, but I enjoyed the way she played with fragments and structure throughout the collection. The story that was an inventory, the story that was episode recaps, the story that was literal and growing gaps in memory (and also dresses), the one about missing parts of one's own body -- that all really resonated with me, who is interested in what happens when there are gaps in a narrative or continuity that have to be filled up somehow. (Thanks, Saidiya Hartman and Dionne Brand and decimated Jewish family history.) I thought the way she allowed things to remain unspoken, and asked the reader to try to stretch strings across those big empty spaces, was done very deftly, while at the same time providing a lot of pleasure via what was there on the sentence level. I really enjoyed her way of writing fairly short, but not choppy, sentences with relatively simple vocabulary but a lot of color words, unexpected verb-noun combinations, and rhythmic paragraph-level structure. It made much of the text feel sort of dreamy and unreal, which is a favorite prose-mood of mine. Yeah, and I also just liked the conceit of urban legend retellings -- it was obvious to me she was very influenced by Angela Carter, but this was like the "low culture" version of that, and I never felt that she was setting herself up to be immune to the silliness or oddity or baroqueness of her source texts, be that fireside stories or zombie movies or Law and Order. Instead, she would happily include that into the stories themselves. (Admittedly, "The Resident" is a bad short story. But the rest made up for it, for me.) Also, great cover. I like the throat-corset.
ahhh thank you so much for all this... my literary analysis repertoire isn't that great yet so i apologize in advance but i think what i disliked the most was the repetitiviness of the themes? at least the first few stories felt similar to me, at one point i was like okay the protagonist is a bisexual woman and men suck... what else can you tell me? i don't know, none of the stories really got to me in terms of provoking a reaction besides the first one.
also resident really was.. something. it definitely had the most cringe worthy dialogue from the book from what i remember. “You know. That old trope. Writing a story where the female protagonist is utterly batty. It’s sort of tiresome and regressive and, well, done”—here she gesticulated so forcefully that a few drops of red spattered the tablecloth—“don’t you think? And the mad lesbian, isn’t that a stereotype as well? Do you ever wonder about that? I mean, I’m not a lesbian, I’m just saying.” like hello??? what the hell is this. the book just had a lot of moments where i rolled my eyes and moved on, but that was definitely about the substance and not the actual prose.
LOL yessss the Resident is TERRIBLE, just give me your whole-chested, name-naming Myriam Gurba rant in the LARB. Just TELL us who the worst people in your MFA were; inquiring minds want to know.
And I think that's all fair! I definitely think her best stories were the ones where all protagonists were women, or when it went really deep into one POV. Such is the nature of different strokes for different folks.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
no subject
actually im curious to hear why you enjoyed her body and other parties because i found it so underwhelming? i read it last month and the first story was really good but none of the others really lived it up to it. but thats just my opinion of course!!!
ambiguity machines sounds awesome!! and i'll look into the others as well i really appreciate your comment
no subject
no subject
also resident really was.. something. it definitely had the most cringe worthy dialogue from the book from what i remember. “You know. That old trope. Writing a story where the female protagonist is utterly batty. It’s sort of tiresome and regressive and, well, done”—here she gesticulated so forcefully that a few drops of red spattered the tablecloth—“don’t you think? And the mad lesbian, isn’t that a stereotype as well? Do you ever wonder about that? I mean, I’m not a lesbian, I’m just saying.” like hello??? what the hell is this. the book just had a lot of moments where i rolled my eyes and moved on, but that was definitely about the substance and not the actual prose.
no subject
And I think that's all fair! I definitely think her best stories were the ones where all protagonists were women, or when it went really deep into one POV. Such is the nature of different strokes for different folks.